Christian VS Atheist Men - Dating Preferences. This is a response to a video titled "How Christian Guys. An atheist and a Christian are not compatible. .. that when I became a Christian 8 years ago, I had been dating an atheist guy for 3 years. "I'm a confirmed atheist, I'm a born again atheist, basically I make . one of the following groups - no religion, and Christian or Muslim and Sikh.